|
The Feature
The Other Election
You have been hearing about the midterms all year. Almost nobody can tell you what is actually being decided. Here is the whole thing on one page.
A polling place before the doors open. In a midterm year, more than half the country never walks through them.
Photo: Pexels.
You have been hearing about the midterms all year. In ads, in arguments, on every podcast you half listen to in the car. Ask most men what the midterms actually decide and you get a shrug. They know it is another time to vote. That is about where it stops. So here is what is actually on the paper.
It is Tuesday, November 3. On the ballot are all 435 seats in the House of Representatives, 35 of the 100 seats in the Senate, and 36 governorships. No president. That is the whole reason it is called a midterm. It lands in the middle of a presidential term.
Those governor races touch your week more than most men assume. A governor signs state tax law, runs the state police and the National Guard, and appoints the people who regulate your insurance and your professional license. Thirty-six of those jobs get decided in November.
Every seat in the House is up because House terms are two years long. All of them. Every two years, without exception, the entire House gets torn down and rebuilt. Senators serve six years and their terms are staggered in thirds. Only about a third of the Senate is ever on a ballot at once. This year that is 35 seats, two of which are special elections to fill a seat early.
Here is the part almost nobody can explain. The two chambers do not do the same job. A bill has to pass both of them to become law, which makes them equal partners on legislation. Everywhere else they split. The Senate alone confirms federal judges, Supreme Court justices, and the president's cabinet. The House alone starts any bill that raises money, which means tax law begins there. Holding one chamber and not the other hands you a very different set of tools.
Right now Republicans hold both. The Senate is 53 to 47. The House is 218 to 214 with two seats sitting vacant. Read that second number again. The working majority in the House is four seats. A handful of districts changing hands flips control of an entire chamber of Congress.
Now the pattern, which is close to the most reliable thing in American politics and which almost nobody knows. Since 1946, there have been twenty midterms. In eighteen of them the president's party lost seats in the House. That is ninety percent of the time. The average loss runs about twenty-five seats.
It is not a partisan quirk. It happens to whoever is sitting in the White House. Clinton lost 54 seats in 1994. Obama lost 63 in 2010, the worst of the modern era. Trump lost about 40 in 2018. Republicans took the House back from Biden's party in 2022. The only two presidents since the Second World War whose party gained House seats in a midterm were Clinton in 1998 and Bush in 2002.
How big the loss gets tracks one thing more than any other, which is how popular the president happens to be at the time. Gallup has been measuring it for decades. When a president sits above fifty percent approval going into a midterm, his party loses about fourteen seats. Below fifty, it loses about thirty-six.
The reason underneath all of it is turnout. The gap is wider than people realize. So far this century about sixty-four percent of eligible Americans vote in a presidential year. In a midterm it is about forty-eight. That is sixteen points of the country that only turns up when there is a president on the ballot. Those people are not spread evenly across both sides. Satisfied voters stay home. Angry voters drive.
If a chamber flips, the effect is less dramatic than people expect and a lot more grinding. Big legislation mostly stops because nothing becomes law without both chambers agreeing. Government starts running on short funding extensions instead of real budgets. Confirmations slow down or stop entirely. None of that is a prediction about who should win. It is just how the machine behaves when the two halves disagree.
Here is the part worth keeping. The entire House gets demolished and rebuilt every two years. The version you end up with is chosen by the smaller, stranger slice of the country that bothers to show up in a year with no president on the ballot. Fewer people vote. The margins are thinner. A few thousand votes spread across a few districts decide who runs a chamber of Congress. Whatever you think of any of the people involved, that means your one vote carries more weight in November than it did in 2024. That is not an argument for a side. That is arithmetic.
|